Slow Living vs Simple Living: Finding Room for What Matters

There is something rather satisfying about opening a cupboard and finding everything exactly where it belongs. I have experienced this pleasure many times over the years, usually shortly after deciding that our household has accumulated far too much and spending an afternoon sorting through its contents. For a little while, everything seems wonderfully manageable. There is room to reach the things we use every day, nothing falls out when the door opens, and I find myself wondering why we ever needed so much in the first place. Yet inevitably, life begins to fill those spaces again. Something is brought home, something else is kept because it might be useful, and before long the cupboard has returned to its familiar, slightly overcrowded state.

I used to think this was something I ought to get better at preventing. There seemed to be a certain virtue in owning less, in being able to open a drawer without encountering the accumulated evidence of several years of family life. I admired the idea of a simple home, where everything had a purpose and very little existed beyond what was necessary. But the longer I have lived, particularly as a parent and through the many changes our family has experienced, the more I have come to question what we really mean when we talk about living simply. I have discovered that some of the things I value most are precisely those that would be difficult to justify keeping if usefulness were the only consideration.

Slow living vs simple living is often spoken about as though they are interchangeable. Both encourage us to reconsider the pace and complexity of modern life, and both offer an appealing alternative to the constant pressure to acquire more, accomplish more and somehow fit more into the hours available to us. Yet I have come to think there is an important difference between them, one that becomes especially apparent when we begin applying these ideas to the ordinary, complicated business of living.

The Difficulty of Enough

As a parent, I have found that some of the things I am least willing to part with are those that have long since outlived their practical purpose. I still have things I bought for my son when he was very young, tucked away in boxes that have followed us through more house moves than I can count. There are toys he no longer plays with and little belongings that once formed such an ordinary part of our days that I scarcely noticed them at the time. Now, when I come across them, I remember the child he was when they were first his. I cannot quite understand the argument for getting rid of something simply because it is no longer being used. Perhaps one day he will have children of his own, and perhaps he will take pleasure in placing something familiar from his childhood into their hands.

My mother-in-law understood this instinct. She kept a box of my partner's childhood belongings, and watching our son discover its contents has been one of those lovely, unexpected pleasures of family life. He examines each thing with enormous interest and takes particular pride in knowing that something which once belonged to his father now belongs to him. I imagine my mother-in-law could never have known, when she first packed those things away, quite how much pleasure they would bring another child years later. There is a kind of continuity in that exchange which no newly purchased object could quite reproduce. Something ordinary has become part of a family history, and its value has grown simply because someone thought it worth keeping.

We have inherited other boxes under sadder circumstances, when family members have died and left behind possessions that suddenly carry the weight of an entire life. These are things we may never use, yet the thought of parting with them feels strangely close to losing the person all over again. I sometimes wonder whether our enthusiasm for decluttering has made us too quick to dismiss the importance of keeping things.

We live in a society that encourages us to replace what is old, discard what is inconvenient and make room for whatever comes next. Yet for generations, families kept things precisely because they had belonged to someone before. A familiar object could pass through several households and acquire a history far greater than its original purpose. I find something deeply comforting in that older understanding of possessions, where their value might grow with age rather than diminish. Perhaps keeping certain things is one small way of resisting the disposability of modern life, of preserving a little of the past for people who have yet to arrive.

Our own circumstances have made this relationship with possessions rather complicated. We have moved house so many times that I have lost count, and through every move those boxes have come with us. Living in a small space and travelling in our caravan has taught us to be much more deliberate about what we bring into our lives. There is only so much room, and we have become accustomed to making do with what we already own. I have learned to appreciate how little we genuinely need on an ordinary day, and there is a certain freedom in knowing that most of what matters to us can be accommodated within a relatively small space.

Still, I would be pretending if I said I never missed having a house where I could unpack everything and live amongst the things I love. I miss seeing familiar belongings on shelves, having room for books collected over the years, and allowing the evidence of our family life to remain visible rather than carefully packed away. There are times when I long for the sort of home that gradually gathers the history of the people living in it, where things are allowed to stay long enough to become part of the place. I can appreciate the simplicity of our present circumstances while still missing the comfort of being surrounded by the things we have carried through our lives.

This is where I think simple living becomes much more interesting than the carefully arranged images we often associate with it. There is no particular number of possessions that makes a life simple, and I doubt two families would arrive at the same understanding of what is necessary. What feels excessive to one person may be deeply meaningful to another. For me, simplicity has gradually become a question of knowing what is enough for the life we want to live, and being willing to make room for the things that genuinely matter, even when keeping them is inconvenient.

A Different Kind of Clutter

Slow living, I think, asks something slightly different of us. I have spent enough time in small spaces to know that a tidy home does not necessarily produce a peaceful mind. There have been afternoons in our caravan when everything was put away, the day's work was finished and there was no particular reason to hurry, yet I found myself mentally occupied with what needed doing tomorrow. I could be sitting beside my family, listening to a conversation, and gradually become aware that my attention had wandered towards an unfinished task. The room itself was perfectly calm, but I had somehow managed to carry the noise of the outside world into it.

I recognise this habit more readily now, perhaps because I have spent so much time thinking about what it means to live slowly. There is a tendency to imagine that once we have simplified our surroundings, the rest will naturally follow. We picture a quieter home, fewer commitments and long stretches of uninterrupted time, and assume that somewhere within those changes we will finally discover the feeling of having enough hours in the day. Sometimes reducing the demands upon us genuinely helps. But I have also noticed how easily we can hurry through an afternoon that contains very little, particularly when our thoughts have become accustomed to racing ahead of whatever we are doing.

I think this is one of the reasons slow living can be difficult to understand from the outside. We have become familiar with a particular picture of it, usually involving a beautiful old house, a wooden table and the sort of kitchen where bread is made by hand. I happen to love these things myself, and would be delighted to spend an afternoon in such a place. Yet I have also known perfectly ordinary evenings, in homes that were neither especially beautiful nor particularly organised, when everyone remained around the table long after the meal was finished because the conversation was too good to leave. Looking back, those evenings seem to me a much more reliable expression of slow living than any carefully arranged room.

There is something reassuring about this, especially for those of us whose lives do not always resemble the images we admire. We can be living in a caravan, surrounded by the practical limitations of a small space, and still experience the pleasure of an unhurried day. Equally, we can have the home we have always dreamed of and spend so much time maintaining it, improving it or worrying about it that we scarcely enjoy being there. The surroundings of our lives matter, of course, and I believe they can influence how we feel. But the ability to appreciate an ordinary moment seems to depend much more upon the attention we bring to it.

This is perhaps the clearest distinction I have found between the two ways of living. Simplicity encourages me to consider what I am bringing into my life and whether I have room for it. Slowing down helps me notice the life already taking place around me. One has made me more thoughtful about what we acquire, while the other has made me increasingly aware of how easily an ordinary day can pass without being properly experienced. I find both valuable, although I no longer expect them to lead me towards exactly the same sort of life.

When Simplicity Becomes Complicated

For a long time, I imagined that simplifying our lives was something we could eventually finish. If we could work out what mattered, let go of what didn't and establish a sensible way of managing the remainder, perhaps there would come a point when everything settled into place. We would have the right amount of possessions, a manageable number of commitments and enough time left over to enjoy ourselves. I suspect this is part of the appeal of simplicity: the possibility that life might become easier to manage if only we could find the correct arrangement.

But family life has a way of undoing even the most carefully considered arrangements. Children grow, interests change and the things that once occupied an important place in our days gradually make way for something else. A household that seemed perfectly organised at the beginning of the year can look entirely different by the end of it. There have been times when I have cleared a space with great determination, only to discover a few months later that we genuinely needed it for something I could never have anticipated. I have slowly accepted that a home is unlikely to remain in any particular state for very long, especially when the people living in it are curious, growing and making things.

Our time is subject to much the same uncertainty. We can begin a week with every intention of moving slowly, only to find ourselves caught up in work, family responsibilities or some unexpected difficulty that requires our attention. There have been periods in our lives when travelling and living with fewer possessions has given us a wonderful sense of freedom, and others when the practical demands of that same lifestyle have left us longing for the stability of a permanent home. I have learned that simplicity does not remove the complications of being human. Sometimes it merely changes the form they take.

I think we can become unnecessarily hard on ourselves when the life we are living begins to look different from the one we had hoped to create. We notice that our days have become busy again, or that our surroundings are less orderly than we would like, and begin searching for another way to simplify. Yet there is a danger in turning these ideas into something we must continually achieve. If every possession needs to justify its existence and every afternoon must be spent in a suitably unhurried manner, we may find ourselves adding an entirely new set of expectations to lives that were already demanding enough.

I have come to appreciate the difference between making thoughtful choices and trying to maintain a perfect arrangement. Our caravan has taught us to consider purchases carefully because the consequences of bringing something home are immediately apparent. If we acquire something new, we must find somewhere to put it, and there is little pleasure in living with belongings that constantly get in the way. But I would never want that practical lesson to become a belief that owning less is inherently better. Nor would I want the desire to live slowly to make me resent the busy seasons of family life, many of which are busy precisely because something meaningful is happening.

Perhaps we need to allow these ideas to change alongside us. The simplicity that suits a young family may look quite different from the simplicity we want when our children are grown. The pace that feels comfortable during a quiet season may be impossible to maintain when someone we love needs extra care. There will be times when we have room for new interests and others when we must set things aside. I think there is wisdom in recognising these changes as part of a life unfolding, rather than evidence that we have somehow lost our way.

Slow Living vs Simple Living - What Remains

Every so often, I find myself thinking about those boxes we have carried from one home to another. They have survived moves, changes of circumstance and all the practical conversations about what we really need to keep. Some contain things we could easily replace, although the replacements would mean very little to us. Others hold belongings that will probably remain packed away until we have a home with enough space to bring them out again. I sometimes imagine that day, when I might open a box that has been closed for years and find myself unexpectedly transported back to a time I had almost forgotten.

I think about my son opening his father's childhood box and the pleasure he takes in those small discoveries. There is something wonderful about knowing that an object can spend years tucked away in a cupboard and still have another chapter waiting for it. My mother-in-law could have cleared those things out long ago, and perhaps nobody would have questioned her decision. Instead, she kept them, and years later a little boy has been given something of his father's childhood to make part of his own. I find myself hoping that some of the things I have saved will one day bring him the same pleasure, even if it means carrying them through a few more house moves in the meantime.

Living simply has made me more conscious of the things we bring into our home, and I am grateful for that. I have little desire to accumulate possessions merely for the sake of having them, particularly when I know how quickly a household can become overwhelmed by things nobody really wanted in the first place. Yet living slowly has made me equally conscious of the things that deserve to remain. It has encouraged me to consider the history of an object, the memories attached to it and the possibility that its usefulness may have very little to do with the purpose for which it was originally made.

I think the two ideas meet somewhere within this understanding. Simple living asks us to recognise when we have enough, while slow living encourages us to pay attention to what that enough contains. Sometimes we need to clear a little space before we can properly appreciate what remains. At other times, slowing down long enough to look at what we already own may remind us that we have no need to acquire anything more. There is no reason these decisions must always lead towards a smaller home, an emptier cupboard or a quieter calendar. They may simply help us become more deliberate about the lives we are creating.

This is why I have grown less interested in the appearance of simplicity and more interested in the feeling of being at home in one's own life. I want to have enough room to move comfortably through our days, enough freedom to enjoy the things that matter and enough time to notice the people sharing them with me. But I also want to keep the old boxes, the books I have carried from place to place and the little pieces of family history that may one day find their way into another pair of hands.

For now, some of those things will have to remain packed away. We have learned to live with less around us, and there is much about that life I genuinely enjoy. Still, I look forward to the possibility of a home where I can unpack those boxes and allow their contents to become part of our everyday surroundings again. I suspect the shelves will be rather full, and there will eventually be cupboards that need sorting. Perhaps that is simply what happens when a home has been lived in long enough to gather a history.

I no longer think there is anything particularly wrong with that.

---

There is still something lovely about finding a story in the letterbox.

The Letterbox at the Cottage is home to The Print Circle bringing dòigh beatha to your door each month, together with a collectable art postcard, a personal letter from Julie Ann and access to the weekly audio stories of The Listening Room.

SEE WHAT'S INSIDE THE LETTERBOX